Skip to content
Wheels Accident Advice

Insurance Claims

Accident in a Rental Car: Who Pays for the Damage and the Injuries

Crashed a rental car? See which policy pays first, what the rental company can bill you for, and how a federal law limits the company's own liability.

By Serdar Arslan, editor · Last reviewed · 8 min read · How we research

When you crash a rental car, the person who caused the crash is still the one whose insurance should pay for the harm. What changes is the order in which policies pay. Damage to the rental car itself usually lands on you first, and you then cover it with your own auto policy, a damage waiver you bought at the counter, or a credit card benefit. Injuries usually go through your own personal injury protection (PIP), medical payments coverage or health insurance, and then the at-fault driver's liability insurer. The rental company is generally not liable just because it owns the car. A federal law, the Graves Amendment, says so, as long as the company was not negligent itself.

Three situations, three different answers

Who pays depends mostly on who caused the crash and whether you were the renter.

You were driving the rental and you caused the crash. Your liability coverage pays the other driver's damage and injuries, if your policy extends to rental cars. Damage to the rental car itself is a separate question, covered below. If you have no auto policy and bought no liability protection at the counter, you may be facing the other driver's claim on your own.

You were driving the rental and another driver caused the crash. The other driver's liability insurer owes the damage they caused, including damage to the rental car and your injuries. In practice, the rental company will often bill you or your insurer first and leave the two insurers to sort it out. Your insurer can then seek repayment from the at-fault driver's insurer, a process called subrogation.

Someone driving a rental car hit you. You claim against the renter's liability coverage, which may be their own auto policy, a liability product they bought from the rental company, or both. You generally cannot sue the rental company just because it owns the car. You still can if the company itself did something wrong, such as renting out a car it knew had bad brakes. In some states the company also has to carry a minimum amount of coverage on the car, discussed below.

What the Graves Amendment does

The federal law at 49 U.S.C. § 30106, known as the Graves Amendment, protects companies in the business of renting or leasing vehicles. Under it, the owner is not liable under state law, simply for being the owner, for harm that happens while someone else is renting the car. Two conditions apply: the owner must be in the rental or leasing business, and there must be no negligence or criminal wrongdoing on the owner's part.

Two limits matter. First, the law does not protect a company that was negligent on its own, for example by renting to someone it knew could not drive safely or failing to maintain the car. Second, it does not override state laws that set financial responsibility or insurance standards for vehicle owners, or that hold rental companies liable when they fail to meet those insurance requirements.

Florida as an example

Florida shows how a state rule can sit next to the federal one. Under Fla. Stat. § 324.021(9)(b)2, a company that rents or leases a car for less than 1 year is treated as the owner for liability purposes only up to $100,000 per person and $300,000 per incident for bodily injury and $50,000 for property damage. If the renter or driver was uninsured or carried less than $500,000 in combined liability coverage, the company can owe up to an additional $500,000 in economic damages, reduced by what is actually recovered from the renter, the driver or their insurance. The statute also says nothing in that paragraph changes the company's liability for its own negligence.

How this rule and the Graves Amendment fit together in a given case is a question for a Florida attorney. Our Florida car accident law page covers the state's no-fault and PIP rules, and the state law index links every state.

Who pays for damage to the rental car

This is where most renters get surprised. The rental agreement usually makes you responsible for damage to the car while you have it, regardless of who caused the crash. Your options for covering that bill are:

Source What it may pay Watch for
Your own auto policy Damage to the rental from a crash or theft, if your collision and comprehensive coverage extends to rentals Your deductible; some policies cover only a temporary substitute car
Collision damage waiver (CDW) or loss damage waiver (LDW) bought at the counter The rental company agrees not to charge you for damage Conditions in the rental agreement can void it
Credit card benefit Some damage, often after other coverage pays Usually secondary; may exclude peer-to-peer rentals
The at-fault driver's insurer All of it, if the other driver caused the crash Pays only after accepting liability

The Texas Department of Insurance says some auto policies cover damage to a rental car from a wreck or theft, that you would pay your deductible, and that people without auto insurance are responsible for any damage to the rental. It also describes the credit card coverage that comes with many cards as secondary, meaning your auto policy pays first.

The California Department of Insurance warns that not every auto policy automatically covers rental vehicles. Some cover a rental only when it is a replacement or substitute car while your own car is in the shop. Call your agent before you rely on your policy.

Loss of use, administrative fees and diminished value

The bill from a rental company often has more on it than the repair. The Utah Insurance Department points to loss of use charges, for the days the car cannot be rented out, and administrative fees as problems renters run into after a crash. It suggests reading the rental agreement for that language and asking both your credit card company and your insurer whether they cover those charges.

Some rental companies also claim diminished value, the drop in what the car is worth after a crash even once it is repaired. Our diminished value guide explains how that loss is usually measured.

Ask the rental company for an itemized bill, the repair invoice and photos, and send copies to whoever is handling the claim. If the bill comes later as a demand letter from a recovery company, read our guide on subrogation demand letters before you agree to pay.

Who pays for your injuries

Injury coverage is usually personal to you, not tied to the car you were driving.

  • PIP or medical payments coverage on your own policy. The Texas Department of Insurance says these coverages will cover your injuries in a rental car crash. In no-fault states, PIP is the first stop. See no-fault vs. at-fault insurance.
  • Health insurance. It can pay bills while the claim is pending, and may ask to be repaid from a later settlement.
  • The at-fault driver's liability insurer. If someone else caused the crash, their insurer owes your injury damages, subject to fault rules and policy limits.
  • Uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. If the at-fault driver has little or no insurance, your own UM/UIM coverage may apply. See our UM and UIM guide.
  • Personal accident insurance from the rental company. The Utah Insurance Department describes this as medical coverage for the renter and passengers and says you likely do not need it if you have adequate health and disability coverage or PIP.

If you were partly at fault, most states reduce what you collect from the other driver by your share. See comparative fault explained.

If you had no auto insurance of your own

Many people who rent do not own a car. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that without auto insurance you will be responsible for damage to the rental, and suggests that buying the rental company's coverage may make sense in that case. For people who rent often, it mentions non-owned auto coverage, a policy for drivers who do not own a vehicle, so you do not have to buy coverage at the counter each time.

If you caused the crash, had no auto policy and declined the counter liability coverage, the other driver or their insurer may come to you directly. Check what your rental agreement says about any liability coverage the company provides, and read sued after a car accident if a lawsuit arrives.

Business trips and peer-to-peer rentals

Work rentals. The Texas Department of Insurance says the rules are different for business travel and suggests checking with your employer. If you were hurt while working, workers' compensation may also be involved.

Car sharing apps. The California Department of Insurance warns that peer-to-peer car sharing programs are not the same as traditional rentals. Insurers and credit card companies may treat them differently, and may exclude damage to a shared car, leaving you responsible. California defines these programs in Insurance Code § 11580.24. Read the app's protection terms before you drive. The Utah Insurance Department adds that your own policy may limit coverage for longer rentals and for driving outside the United States.

What to do after a crash in a rental car

  1. Handle the scene the usual way. Call 911 if anyone is hurt, call police, exchange information and take photos. Our after-a-crash checklist covers each step.
  2. Get the police report number. Rental companies and insurers often ask for it. See how to get a police accident report.
  3. Report the crash to the rental company by the deadline in your rental agreement, and keep a record of when and how you reported it.
  4. Notify your own insurer and, if you paid with a card that offers rental coverage, the card issuer. Card benefits may have their own reporting deadlines.
  5. Photograph the rental car at the scene and when you return it.
  6. Ask for every charge in writing before you pay anything beyond your deductible or the amount your coverage requires.
  7. Keep medical, wage and expense records for your injury claim, and note your state's filing deadline with the statute of limitations calculator.

When to get help

A lawyer is worth a call if you were seriously hurt, if the rental company may have been negligent, or if you face a large claim without insurance. See do I need a lawyer.

Rules on owner liability, required coverage and fault vary by state. Before relying on anything here, open your state's page on our car accident laws index, for example Texas, California or Utah, and call your state insurance department with coverage questions.

Sources

  1. 49 U.S.C. § 30106: Rented or leased motor vehicle safety and responsibility (Cornell LII)
  2. Fla. Stat. § 324.021: Definitions; minimum insurance required (flsenate.gov)
  3. Texas Department of Insurance: Do I need to buy insurance when I rent a car?
  4. Utah Insurance Department: Rental Car Coverage
  5. California Department of Insurance: Consumer Alert on Insurance Coverage for Rental Cars (2023)